AdultDVDTalk Review

46,154 reviews from 1,038 reviewers is how this community describes its own output, and the second number is the unusual one. Sites of this age report what they hold; this one reports how many people wrote it, alongside 327,016 films, 123,316 trailers and 65,665 members, dated back to 1999.

The structure follows from that. Reviews are sorted three ways on the front page — new, most read, and reviewers recommend — and each entry carries a byline, a studio and a director, so the writer is credited the way the film is.

Navigation is still built around buying: new releases, coming soon, where to buy, top 50, shopping information. The site makes its own joke about the format being dead and keeps the shelves anyway.

The only heading rendered on the page belongs to somebody else — a retailer's current top ten performers.

Separate rooms exist for gay releases, for industry news, and for members who are performers or directors. An account is needed to write, not to read.